AKA Marketing.com Logo            VISIT THE BLOG            

Blogged thoughts, is our web blog. Expect views, opinion, rants and tirades about everything and anything 

« Home / Forums »        

 


Subscribe to our SEO / IT related blog by entering your email address below

Blogged thoughts

| by the www.akamarketing.com team



Google finding website location differently than Yahoo/MSN

Just noticed this last night, my site doesn’t appear in the ‘in Ireland’ results on Yahoo.co.uk nor does it appear in the ‘Only from Ireland’ results on search.msn.ie it does however appear in the ‘pages from Ireland’ results on Google.ie.

Here’s a little secret - my site is actually physically hosted in the United States however its IP blocks are registered to Shannon, County Clare so this seems sufficent to ‘fool’ Google, but not Yahoo and MSN. I would have thought it would have been the other way around.

It probably actually doesn’t make much of a difference to me in terms of visitors but I would like to know how this works, perhaps Google being a domain name registrar looks at where akamarketing.com is hosted and checks the registered address of the host. no? What gives?

14 Comments on “Google finding website location differently than Yahoo/MSN”
1| Richard Hearne said,

Hi Dave

TO the best of my knowledge Google looks for 2 things when geo-targeting:
1. the ccTLD;
2. the location where the IP is registered (not resolved to)

This means that to get listed in the Google country index you have to either have a ccTLD from that country or your IP address has to be registerd in that country.

Its a slight quirk - some people think it is to do with the physical location of the hosted server but I have heard it is based on where the IP is registered. Google sitemaps blog have an entry that states you should host in the country you belong to.

I have heard that hosts have had issues with this when their servers are physically hosted in one country but the IP blocks for those servers were registered in the US.

I reckon a good person to ask about this would be Michele over at Blacknight - this would really be in his area.

2| David Callan said,

Hi Richard, thanks for your views. Yes this is what I believe Google looks at too.

When you say “issues” what exactly do you mean? I haven’t had any problems with my webhost as of yet.
There is obviously just some difference in the way Google and Yahoo/MSN approach these things.. that was the point I was making.

I wonder though could it actually be the fact that MSN/YAHOO are slower to update their site information, as up to about 2 months ago I was hosted with a 100% USA host with IP registered in the US too. To counter this argument though I checked on some of my webhosts current clients and they don’t seem to appear to be in the ‘only from Ireland’ pages neither.
Could it possibly be that Yahoo and MSN is more sophisticated than Google.

Not to worry though as Google is of course the main player on the block.

3| Martin said,

Hi Dave,

The fact that Google is displaying your site in the “Pages From Ireland” category and you DONT have a ccTld proves that it is indeed indexing your site by the Irish registered IP . The majority of our IP’s are registered to an Irish address , not USA .

Can you tell me which websites you checked ? I would be interested to see which IP’s they are using as some IP’s are UK and USA based

Kind Rgds
Martin

4| David Callan said,

Hi Martin,
I think your getting the wrong end of the stick here…. I’m not having a go at you or your company, as far as I’m concerned my site is acting exactly how I want it to on Google. I’m just wondering how Yahoo and MSN work in respect to specific country pages only as they obviously differ from Google. I am a search engine optimisation consultant afterall and trying to figure out how Google, Yahoo and MSN work is my job.

I checked the Evoco Creative website.
http://www.google.ie/search?hl=en&q=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.evococreative.com%2F&btnG=Google+Search&meta=cr%3DcountryIE

http://search.msn.ie/results.aspx?q=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.evococreative.com%2F&FORM=QBNO&rf=1

Yahoo and MSN must be checking the resolved to address I believe.

5| Martin said,

Hey Dave

I know your not having a go :) , I am genuinely interested in this. The website you checked, up until recently, was using a UK registered IP address . Perhaps your right in that MSN and YAHOO checks if the ccTld relates to the ‘Pages From Ireland’ search (i.e it checks if its a .IE domain) and if not, bases it on the origination of the IP ??

Although, The following are websites we host using an Irish IP

http://uk.search.yahoo.com/search?p=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.lenanetoolanddie.com&ei=UTF-8&fr=FP-tab-web-t340&x=wrt&meta=vc%3DcountryIE

http://uk.search.yahoo.com/search?p=www.fanahanscollege.com&fr=FP-tab-web-t340&ei=UTF-8&meta=vc%3DcountryIE

http://uk.search.yahoo.com/search?p=www.frameworksfilms.com&fr=FP-tab-web-t340&ei=UTF-8&meta=vc%3DcountryIE

If you find out any more info please be sure to send it my way .

Thanks Dave,

Kind Rgds
Martin

6| Janine said,

my .com domain is hosted in texas. as a result, google and msn do not see me as irish, but yahoo does. i blogged about this a while back and the verdict was that yahoo were reading the info from the domain whois record??

7| David Callan said,

Martin thanks for the heads up on them sites. But are they physically hosted in Ireland, the US or somewhere else? Their IPs are resolved to Ireland? or are they registered to Ireland?

Hi Janine, very interesting. Can you provide the link to this discussion on your blog? Is your IP registered to Ireland I wonder? So the domain whois record would have the domain owners address (most likely) and you reckon Yahoo could be looking at this? Yahoo has been a domain name registrar for a awful lot longer than Google.

8| Martin said,

Hi Dave

Those sites are physically hosted in the USA but the IP’S are registered to an Irish address . The domain names are registered to Irish addresses (domain owners)

Rgds
Martin

9| David Callan said,

This is exactly the same setup as me. I couldn’t get access to the domain name records for any of them sites you gave though on http://www.betterwhois.com/. I tried akamarketing.com however and my listing showed. One thing I noticed was that my address is actually listed as::

David Callan
12 Lorcan Crescent
Santry, Dublin 9
IE

The record can be seen here :: http://www.betterwhois.com/bwhois.cgi?domain=akamarketing.com&x=33&y=5
As we can see Ireland is actually shortened to IE, perhaps Yahoo (and MSN?) is looking at this and not spotting it as Ireland. It really should be proper full addressing so I might get in touch with dreamhost.com who I registered the domain with and ask them to update it.

Martin all registrars now just use their own domain databases so I think to get a good look at the records of the domains you list we will need to know who they are registered with, is it with your company?

10| Janine said,

hi david,
well, it wasn’t really a discussion but here’s the link anyway! :) http://www.janinedalton.com/blog/archives/2005/yahoo-knows-where-i-live/

i’m a bit confused about how you find where an ip physically resolves to versus where it is registered. so maybe this won’t show the right info, but it looks to me like the ip my domain is hosted on is both registered in and hosted in texas? http://www.dnsstuff.com/tools/whois.ch?ip=67.19.14.18

it’s interesting to know that the registration details of the ip have a baring. i had always assumed just where the site was hosting was what counted. you learn something new every day! :)

11| Martin said,

Hi David

It depends on the customer, some come to use with pre registered domains and look after billing themeselves, others dont . For new registrations we use Enom.

Rgds
Martin

12| Richard Hearne said,

Just looking back here.

‘Issues’ as in Irish/UK hosts having blocks of IPs that are registered in the US. So people signing up believe that they are hosted in the UK so will do well in UK SERPs but subsequently find out that the IP is US registered.

I have no direct knowledge of this, and TBH HTTP isn’t really my forte, but I have read some stories of this.

You really need that comment subscription thingy :)

13| David Callan said,

Ok this is getting into deception really when hosts claim to be based in UK when actually they are IP US registered. Myhost told me straight up about their setup and this is different so I do not consider this to be an issue.

OK so I have decided to actually email Yahoo and MSN to see if by chance they might actually reply to my question. This is what I asked::

Hi there, I’m wondering what the factors are for your ‘Ireland only’ results. My sites IP address is registered to Ireland but still I don’t show up for a search on my company name - akamarketing.com on yahoo.co.uk search. Does it depend where is domain name registrar is located? Curious to know how this part of your results is handled.

Obviously I changed the above to be correct when contacting MSN.
Janine I see your whois record has IE also as opposed to Ireland so it must not be the issue for akamarketing.com.

I’ll let people know if I get any reply.

14| Galen - Lucid Design said,

Does anyone else not see this as a fairly major flaw in Google’s system? Google is designed, I believe, to be diplomatic and fair in finding the most relevant sites but the reality is that many many sites are hosted in the US and there’s not a lot of alternatives. We are in New Zealand and I’m not sure that there is even a server located here that offers the services we offer—Ruby on Rails etc. It’s okay when a site has a .co.nz or .org.nz domain but sometimes we have no choice but to use a .com or .org domain. These sites don’t show in New Zealand-only searches…. what can we do?

Leave a Comment
Name:
Email:
Website:
 
HOME | ABOUT US | CONTACT US | SITEMAP | GOOGLE SITE SEARCH | TOP
12 Lorcan Crescent, Santry, Dublin 9, Ireland +353 87 9807629